R9fkF0cuGLgOy

Court proceedings

Source: licencja: CC 0.

Link to the lesson

Before you start you should know
  • You are able to analyze the functions of law.

  • You are able to name the normative acts regulating the civil and criminal proceedings.

  • You are able to describe the structure of common courts in Poland.

You will learn
  • You will be able to present the course of criminal and civil proceedings.

  • You will be able to explain the rights of victims and perpetratorsperpetratorperpetrators in criminal proceedings.

  • You will be able to explain the rules for appeal and cassation.

  • You will understand the importance of mediation in civil proceedings.

R1XWEnMlh5DeG
nagranie abstraktu

Criminal proceedings

The purpose of criminal proceedings is to determineto determinedetermine whether a crime has been committedto commitcommitted and to detectto detectdetect its perpetrator and hold him criminally liableto hold somebody criminally liablehold him criminally liable.

We are dealing with criminal liabilitycriminal liabilitycriminal liability when:

  • an act was committed which was prohibited by the penalpenalpenal law in force at the time it was committed,

  • the perpetrator has reached the minimum age, allowing for him to be held criminally liable (in Poland it is 17 years),

  • the act was not committed in self defenseself defenseself defense or in a state of higher necessitystate of higher necessitystate of higher necessity,

  • the act was committed culpablyculpablyculpably (nullum crimen sine culpa - no crime without guilt); the fault may be intentional (the perpetrator intends to commit the offence) or unintentional (the perpetrator does not intend to commit an offence, but commits it, e.g. not being cautious enough).

The basic principle of criminal law is also that you are only responsible for your own actions.

A participant in criminal proceedings is any person who participates in proceedings in a role defined by law.

Exercise 1
R9iZajxWmQGo0
Ćwiczenie alternatywne: Do you know who the participants of criminal proceedings are? Give examples of: 1. judicial bodies responsible for the proceedings; 2. parties proceedings; 3. personal sources of evidence; 4. legal representatives 5. parties investigation; legal assistants.

The public prosecutor is usually the state prosecutorstate prosecutorstate prosecutor, but this function may also be performed by police officers, municipal guards, and state labor inspectors. The task of the public prosecutor is to present accusations of committing a prohibited act and support it with evidence.

The subsidiary prosecutorsubsidiary prosecutorsubsidiary prosecutor is a victim who may participate in a criminal trial alongside or instead of a public prosecutor.

private prosecutorprivate prosecutorprivate prosecutor may be a victim or the representative of a victim who raises and supports accusations in cases prosecuted by private accusation.

An accused in a criminal trial is a person against whom an indictment was filedto file an indictment against somebodyindictment was filed before the court or a person against whom the prosecutor filed a motion for conditional discontinuance of proceedings.

R1Qj2du6zUlmF
Grafika przedstawiająca osobę trzymającą symbole paragrafów w obu dłoniach. Nad nią znajduje się drogowskaz z dwoma strzałkami o przeciwnych zwrotach. Jedna z nich jest podpisana "rights" i umieszczono na niej następującą treść: the right to defense including the right to use the assistance of a lawyer, to provide explanations, requests for evidence and to question witnesses and experts, the right to remain silent – the right to refuse to provide explanations and answers to questions, the right to lodge an application for conviction and the verdict of a specific sentence without conducting evidence proceedings (so-called voluntary submission to punishment). Druga z nich została podpisana "obligations" i znajduje się na niej następująca treść: submission to the examination and visual inspection specified by the statute, In the event of accused who has not been detained: an obligation to appear whenever he is called in the course of the proceedings, obligation to notify the court of any change of residence or stay lasting longer than 7 days.
Rights and obligations of the accused
Source: licencja: CC 0.

The criminal proceedings consist of several stages. The preparatory stage includes clarifying the circumstances of the crime, hearing of the witnesses, preparing documents for the court. The trial is conducted before the court of the first instance (district or regional).

RYZ4PI4ZIzul3
Criminal trial overview
Source: GroMar Sp. z o.o., licencja: CC BY-SA 3.0.

Appeal proceedings are carried out in the second instance court (regional or court of appeal) in the case of appeal against the judgment by one of the parties. The reason for filing an appeal include:

  • infringement of the procedural rules, if it could have influenced the content of the judgment under appeal,

  • an error in factual findings which were the basis of the judgment under appeal, if it could have an impact on its content,

  • gross disproportion of punishment.

The court of appeal may:

  • maintain the contested judgment in force,

  • revoke the appealed judgment and direct the case for reconsideration or discontinue the proceedings,

  • change the appealed judgment.

The enforcement proceedings begin when the judgment becomes legally binding. It is the implementation of the court's judgment (e.g. imprisonment).

In criminal proceedings, there is a possibility to use an extraordinary mean of recourse against the verdict of the court of the second instance – cassation, considered by the Supreme Court. A party (ordinary cassation) or the Attorney General, the Supreme Military Prosecutor or the Ombudsman may appeal in cassation (extraordinary cassation). The reason for filing a cassation may be a serious violation of the provisions of the proceedings or other gross violations of the law, if they could have a significant impact on the content of the court’s decision.

Civil proceedings

Civil liability regards property. It concerns natural persons, legal persons, and the State Treasury.

The basic principle of civil liability is responsibility on guilt basis - just like in criminal law it is a liability for culpable action or omission.

Types of civil liability:

  • for damage caused by a tort,

  • for failure to perform or improper performance of an obligation arising from a legal transaction (e.g. contract),

  • for damage caused as a result of an event (e.g. warranty or insurance).

Civil proceedings are divided into judicial (court) and out‑of‑court ones. In the court procedure, the following stages can be distinguished:

  • examination – in which the case is recognized and resolved,

  • auxiliary – carried out to identify the side‑effects that remain in connection with the main proceedings (e.g. proceedings regarding the reinstatement of the deadline),

  • enforcement – which serves the purpose of meeting the rights and fulfilling the obligations.

Parties in civil proceedings:

  • a plaintiff – the party that initiates proceedings by filing a lawsuit to the court,

  • defendant – the person against whom the lawsuit was directed.

The lawsuit must meet the requirements for procedural documents. It should include, among others, the identification of the court to which it is addressed, the name and surname or the names of the parties, their legal representatives and proxies, the content of the request succinctly described, factual circumstances justifying the request and evidence to support the circumstances cited, the value of the subject (in the case of property claims).

In addition, the lawsuit may contain various types of requests, for example: for securing the claims, conducting the trial in the absence of the plaintiff, summoning witnesses and experts for hearing, making an inspection, requesting evidence to be brought into court for the trial from the court, offices or third parties. The defendant has the right to respond to the claim after is being delivering to him.

According to art. 210 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the hearing takes place in such a way that after calling the party's case - first the plaintiff and then the defendant report their claims and conclusions orally and provide statements and evidence to support them. The parties may also indicate the legal basis of their demands and conclusions. Each party is obliged to make a statement regarding the facts as to the claims of the opposing party. In addition, the trial includes, depending on the circumstances, evidence and analysis of its results. A party may, up to the end of the hearing, cite facts and evidence to substantiate its conclusions or refute the conclusions and claims of the opposing party. The settlement of a case in civil proceedings takes the form of a decision or judgment. In proceedings before the civil courts, you can also appeal to a higher instance and lodge a cassation complaint to the Supreme Court.

Exercise 2

Imagine that you need to file a claim in a Polish court, for example for damages or alimony. Write an example of a lawsuit in Polish, because this is the official language of the Polish judiciary. Remember to address it to the competent court, provide the necessary data and justification. Compare your claim with the suggestions of other students.

R1DiNgkdlgVvI
Wersja alternatywna ćwiczenia. Napisz pozew. Nie zapomnij o takich elementach, jak: miejscowość i data; nazwa i wydział właściwego sądu; powód; pozwany; wartość przedmiotu sporu; czego dotyczy pozew; o co wnosisz w pozwie; uzasadnienie; podpis; załączniki.

Mediations

Mediation is a process of resolving a dispute by the parties involved with the participation of a third party – a mediator - whose task is to help the parties' reach an agreement. A mediator can be any person with full active legal capacity, enjoying full public rights. A judge cannot be a mediator. Mediation is voluntary. It is conducted on the basis of a mediation agreement or a court order that directs parties to mediation. The basic principles of conducting mediation are:

  • voluntariness,

  • impartiality of the mediator,

  • confidentiality,

  • speed.

If mediation leads to a settlement, it must be approved by the court. It has then the same legal force as the settlement made directly before the court. Such a settlement is just as enforceable as a final court decision. Solving a dispute through mediation is very beneficial for both parties and the judiciary. The mediation procedure is many times faster, and allows the parties to find solutions that will satisfy each of them. In addition, it relieves courts, in which civil cases tend to go on for a long time. Mediations are more and more often used in proceedings before criminal and family courts, too.

Proceedings before criminal and civil courts in Poland differ from each other. We initiate criminal proceedings by submitting a notification on suspicion of committing a crime (or through a private indictment), and the civil proceedings - by filing a lawsuit to a court. Proceedings before a criminal court are preceded by preparatory proceedings which are not present in civil proceedings. In civil proceedings, the burden of proof rests with the plaintiff, in criminal proceedings, in most cases, the responsibility to prove guilt lies with the public prosecutor. In civil proceedings, the court is bound by the content of the lawsuit, and in criminal proceedings it is obliged to comprehensively examine the case. Therefore, in criminal cases the scope of the judgment may be broader or narrower than what the victim expects. As far as the similarities are concerned, proceedings before criminal and civil courts have a two‑instance character. The first instance is usually district courts, in exceptional cases regional courts. In both types of proceedings, the same means of recourse apply: an appeal and a cassation (in civil proceedings it is called cassation complaint).

RiwmPmSb8HSLY
Exercise 3
Ćwiczenie alternatywne: Listen to the abstract recording to review the material and new vocabulary. Then do the vocabulary exercise. Explain the meaning of following words: to hold somebody criminally liable; state of higher necessity; investigative bodies; state prosecutor; subsidiary prosecutor; private prosecutor; to file an indictment against somebody; motion for conditional discontinuance of proceedings. If it's too difficult, use lesson's glossary.

Keywords

criminal proceedings, criminal liability, investigative bodies, state prosecutor, subsidiary prosecutor, private prosecutor, the accused, victim, suspect, defense attorney, witness, expert, rights of the accused, first/second instance court, enforcement proceeding, civil liability, responsibility on guilt basis, civil proceedings, plaintiff, defendant, lawsuit, mediation

Glossary

criminal liability
criminal liability
RtbfqrmvFzDP0
Nagranie słówka: criminal liability

odpowiedzialność karna

culpably
culpably
RCw29r6ku1WsN
Nagranie słówka: culpably

w sposób zawiniony

investigative bodies
investigative bodies
RJAcgFZ397m9Z
Nagranie słówka: investigative bodies

organy dochodzeniowe/śledcze

motion for conditional discontinuance of proceedings
motion for conditional discontinuance of proceedings
Rp2QUYkHLVtc1
Nagranie słówka: motion for conditional discontinuance of proceedings

wniosek o warunkowe umorzenie postępowania

penal
penal
RlD3tjreXhXtu
Nagranie słówka: penal

karny

perpetrator
perpetrator
RUuXzElyI77G3
Nagranie słówka: perpetrator

sprawca

private prosecutor
private prosecutor
RgLlTqvfFHObq
Nagranie słówka: private prosecutor

oskarżyciel prywatny

self defense
self defense
RECnyqRnWacWR
Nagranie słówka: self defense

samoobrona

state of higher necessity
state of higher necessity
Rcj5fK1ZwPQ1J
Nagranie słówka: state of higher necessity

stan wyższej konieczności

state prosecutor
state prosecutor
RPVxVYGCe1JHo
Nagranie słówka: state prosecutor

oskarżyciel publiczny

subsidiary prosecutor
subsidiary prosecutor
RyFjzA92lUm6S
Nagranie słówka: subsidiary prosecutor

oskarżyciel posiłkowy

to commit
to commit
Rz5fBpRrBX5JN
Nagranie słówka: to commit

popełnić

to detect
to detect
R1ElMAqGw5857
Nagranie słówka: to detect

ustalić, wykryć

to determine
to determine
RbHQ80sPckGGI
Nagranie słówka: to determine

ustalić

to file an indictment against somebody
to file an indictment against somebody
R1O3ZiHEOC7Xv
Nagranie słówka: to file an indictment against somebody

wnieść przeciwko komuś oskarżenie

to hold somebody criminally liable
to hold somebody criminally liable
Rrm5FxbOcQRkY
Nagranie słówka: to hold somebody criminally liable

pociągnąć kogoś do odpowiedzialności karnej