RmXzLyHb0AGbW

New ideologies: liberalism and conservatism

Constitution of 3 May 1791
Source: Jan Matejko, Constitution of May 3, 1791, 1981, oil on canvas, domena publiczna.

Link to the lesson

You will learn
  • the differences between liberalismliberalismliberalism and conservatism;conservatismconservatism;

  • what the views of leading representatives of liberalism and conservatism were;

  • what were the first feministfeminismfeminist slogans were;

  • who the most important ideologists of liberalism and conservatism were.

RDpiBY4RbqEDI
Nagranie abstraktu

An attempt was made to understand, evaluate, and name the unprecedented experiences that people encountered at the end of the 18th and the first half of the 19th centuries. The great political ideologies of the time, liberalismliberalismliberalism and conservatism;conservatismconservatism;, tried to face this issue. LiberalismliberalismLiberalism proclaimed individual freedom, equality of all citizens before the law and economic freedom. Conservatism;conservatismConservatism;, on the other hand, assumed the preservation of traditional values and the existing social hierarchy.

RyHh3YoxSGtbw
Exercise 1
Oceń poprawność zamieszczonych niżej zdań, zaznaczając te, które streszczają tezy J. Baszkiewicza. Możliwe odpowiedzi: 1. Liberałowie domagali się jednakowych praw politycznych dla wszystkich ludzi, ponieważ są oni sobie równi., 2. Demokraci domagali się jednakowych praw politycznych dla wszystkich ludzi, chociaż są oni różni., 3. Demokraci uważali, że różnice między ludźmi stoją na przeszkodzie w jednakowym uczestnictwie w życiu politycznym., 4. Zdaniem demokratów równość w prawach człowieka powinna prowadzić do równości w prawach obywatela., 5. Liberałowie uważali, że różnice między ludźmi stoją na przeszkodzie w jednakowym uczestnictwie w życiu politycznym., 6. Zdaniem liberałów równość w prawach człowieka powinna prowadzić do równości w prawach obywatela.
Task 1

Look at the timeline. Pay attention to the ideological‑political and economic views of the figures presented. Think about the differences between them.

ROzJmi71Ahw2T1
Leading liberal ideologists 1723 Adam Smith was born (1723–1790)A Scottish thinker and philosopher, a precursor of modern economics. Author of the first economic work Studies on the nature and causes of the wealth of nations (1776). He was a supporter of free trade theory. He introduced the concept of the invisible hand of the market as a set of circumstances determining the behaviour of individuals, which over time was considered as a description of the competition mechanism. He considered the egoism of the individual as something positive, seeing it as the best way of securing the quality of services provided by the individual to others. He did not see the role of technological progress, because he created his works at the dawn of the first industrial revolution that was currently taking place. In his opinion, the role of the state should be limited to protecting citizens against external and internal threats, settling disputes between individuals and protecting the free market and freedom of competition. Thus, the state was to perform the function of a "night watcher", i.e. to guard public order in a way that was not noticed by the majority of citizens., 1748 Jeremy Bentham was born (1748–1832)A philosopher, lawyer and reformer. One of the main representatives of early liberalism, one of the creators of utilitarianism. In his will, he wrote that he passed his body on for scientific purposes, and his mummified skeleton, dressed in period costume and decorated with a wax replica of his head, can still be seen in London. He believed that the rational pursuit of personal happiness increases the general well-being, and that human conduct is moral when it comes to implementing the principle of "the greatest happiness of the greatest number of people"., 1768 Benjamin Constant was born (1767-1830)(French: Henri Benjamin Constant de Rebecque) - A French writer, philosopher and politician of Swiss descent. He was the author of numerous speeches and disquisitions on politics, and an opponent of Napoleon. He is considered to be one of the fathers of liberalism, he was the creator of the theory of constitutional monarchy. He believed that the basic problem was the scope of power, because even the rule of the people could be despotic and impose the will of the individual. However, freedom is the right of the individual to a sphere of privacy, independent from power and others. This freedom is to be guaranteed by the law - the property right and the right to be active in society., 1805 Alexis de Tocqueville was born (1805-1859)A French thinker, historian and politician, Minister of Foreign Affairs since 1848 (during the French Second Republic). In the 1830s, he analysed and described in detail American democracy, which made him famous. He then traveled the entire area of this country, having had thousands of conversations with people of different faiths, ethnic groups, professions, social classes and political views. He noticed not only political institutions unknown in Europe, but also a new, egalitarian social system shaping all areas of collective life. He was convinced that the democratisation of European societies was an inevitable process. However, by democracy he meant not so much a certain type of political system as a type of society, which, depending on the circumstances, may have different political forms. He believed that its evolution into autocracy could and should be prevented by the self-organisation of society. He was also convinced that the individual in a democratic society was characterised by a concentration on private matters, a lack of a sense of responsibility towards society, and a strong envy towards those who had been more successful., 1806 John Stuart Mill was born (1806-1873)Portrayed in the photograph with his long-time associate Helen Taylor - a liberal from the second half of the 19th century, free from the illusions of his predecessors, a bright observer of the reality of the time, aware of the social costs of capitalist changes. Like Bentham, he was a utilitarian, he added new elements to liberal thought. He believed that freedom allows people to live in a dignified way, but as the greatest good it is constantly endangered. It was not only the absolutism of the monarchs that could destroy it. To the same extent, freedom is threatened by the despotism of demagogues who refer to the emotions of the revolted masses. He believed that the cure for such a threat was common education, which should precede the introduction of universal suffrage (i.e. democratisation of political life). He demanded state intervention in defence of the weaker. He was one of the most important allies of women’s emancipatory pursuits in Europe at that time.
Source: Henry William Pickersgill, domena publiczna.
Task 2

Read the following text and take the most important information out of it.

Conservatism;conservatismConservatism; was an attempt to find practical means of preventing a revolution or restoring the old rules of government in the places which the revolution changed. Morally, it means being hostile to change, being attached to the existing state of affairs, and being an advocate of a traditional system of values. In the 19th century, neither the processes of industrialisation, democratisation, emancipation of the individual, processes of secularization, nor the formation of modern countries were accepted. As a philosophical and social doctrine, conservatism;conservatismconservatism; was formed as a result of a dispute with liberal philosophy and the legacy of the EnlightenmentEnlightenmentEnlightenment.

A pessimistic view of human nature was the foundation of the reluctance to change. According to conservatives, its negative tendencies and its attraction to evil are best tempered by religion and upbringing. It was therefore concluded that overturning traditional institutions and laws that impede human freedom would not make it possible in any way to create a better social order. Inequalities are an inherent feature of every society, as people differ in their abilities and education, as well as in their level of wealth. Conservatism;conservatismConservatism; has supported a social system that protects tradition (i.e. Church, religious education, property rights) and gives greater influence to elites (because of their background, education and fortune). It negated the need to introduce the universal suffrage and the principle of political equality of citizens as harmful to the state.

1

The ideological foundations of conservatism;conservatismconservatism; were laid at the end of the 18th century, and they were created mainly by elderly people who were critical of the events of the French Revolution. They were the Irish philosopher Edmund Burke (1729‑1797) and the French philosopher Joseph de Maistre (1753‑1821). Burke believed that politics (and the United Kingdom set an example) should be governed by cautious moderation, resulting from limited faith in the power of human reason. It is better to rely on the „collective reason of the ages” and on the rhythm of the generations, on which social life is supported. De Maistre, on the other hand, claimed that true social order could only be supported by the ruler's authority. In his opinion, the events of the French Revolution were a punishment imposed by Providence on a sinful society. He supported the death penalty as the best remedy for the revolutionary upheaval and a guarantee that the society would function properly.

RKiEqCuJ2qyhI
Edmund Burke
Source: Joshua Reynolds, Edmund Burke, ca. 1769, oil on canvas, domena publiczna.
Exercise 2
Wysłuchaj nagrania abstraktu, wyodrębnij jego części i nadaj im tytuły.
Wysłuchaj nagrania abstraktu, wyodrębnij jego części i nadaj im tytuły.
RwcMQ76323FOU
Obraz przedstawiający portret młodej kobiety.
RvwHSGevD3vfu
Exercise 3
Which of these are the works of Mary Wollstonecraft? Możliwe odpowiedzi: 1. A Vindication Of The Rights Of Woman, 2. An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, 3. Frankenstein, 4. Thoughts On The Education Of Daughters
R1XDPS6zpGZU71
Exercise 4
Łączenie par. Test your knowledge of 19th century political doctrines. Which of the following statements would a conservative (K) and a liberal (L) make? Do you find any thesis common to both ideologies (K-L)? Which sentence does not fit any of them?. Society is and should be constructed hierarchically.. Możliwe odpowiedzi: K, L, K-L, none. The state and state institutions should remove obstacles to the happiness of individuals.. Możliwe odpowiedzi: K, L, K-L, none. People are different.. Możliwe odpowiedzi: K, L, K-L, none. Respect for tradition and religion is the foundation of collective life.. Możliwe odpowiedzi: K, L, K-L, none. The way of progress is a way of revolution, not evolution.. Możliwe odpowiedzi: K, L, K-L, none. The state should be a “night watcher”.. Możliwe odpowiedzi: K, L, K-L, none. Poor and uneducated people should not have the right to vote.. Możliwe odpowiedzi: K, L, K-L, none. The state restricts freedom and must therefore be abolished.. Możliwe odpowiedzi: K, L, K-L, none. An individual should not be limited in any way.. Możliwe odpowiedzi: K, L, K-L, none. Political equality of citizens and universal suffrage are detrimental to the state.. Możliwe odpowiedzi: K, L, K-L, none

Keywords

liberalism, conservatism, ideology, Adam Smith

Glossary

liberalism
liberalism
RZ2fNzr1kkJJN
Nagranie słówka: liberalism

liberalizm – ideologia i kierunek polityczny, według którego wolność jest nadrzędną wartością.

conservatism
conservatism
R19XNlcnbljUh
Nagranie słówka: conservatism

konserwatyzm – ideologia, która bazuje na hasłach obrony porządku społecznego oraz umacniania tradycyjnych wartości (religii, narodu, państwa, rodziny).

utilitarianism
utilitarianism
R122skx6FqCJA
Nagranie słówka: utilitarianism

utylitaryzm – kierunek etyki, wg którego to miarą słuszności postępowania jest użyteczność skutków.

Enlightenment
Enlightenment
RrZgw5t5ZoQ67
Nagranie słówka: Enlightenment

oświecenie – nurt kulturalny oraz okres w historii Europy, szerzący deizm, obojętność religijną, naturalizm i krytykę Kościoła.

absolutism
absolutism
RQDZTz4t7ucab
Nagranie słówka: absolutism

absolutyzm – pogląd, wg którego bezgraniczna władza powinna przysługiwać jednemu człowiekowi lub grupie ludzi.

feminism
feminism
RkTL3fHfg20FA
Nagranie słówka: feminism

feminizm – ideologia, kierunek polityczny i ruch społeczny związany z równouprawnieniem kobiet.