Contemporary political ideologies. Part I
You know what the differences between a democratic and a non‑democratic state are.
You understand the various types of party systems in democratic states.
You are able to explain the ideological differences between “the left” and “the right”.
You will be able to distinguish the relationship between an individual and the government in various political ideologies.
You will be able to justifyjustify the importance of the historical context in the shaping of political ideologies.
You will understand what changes influenced the perception of relations between individuals and the state, and how the scope of individual freedom has changed.
You will be able to compare the views of different ideologies regarding the same problems in state policies.
The word „ideology” comes from the Greek language: idéa - imagination; lógos - word, science. Ideology is a set of values, beliefs, ideas and views describing and evaluating the reality. It is a vision of the existing world and a projection of the future. Ideology is also a set of rules of conduct for social movements and political parties. Ideology consists of philosophical, economic, legal, ethical, religious and artistic concepts. The creators and supporters of each ideology refer to the rights of an individual and his role in society, the functioning of state institutions, changes in the existing social order, freedom and justice. They present a structured image of the existing world, talking about the necessary changes and improvements. They point topoint to an idealistically understood goal that society should aspire to. Ideology usually justifies the entirety of political activities and defines goals to complete at a certain stage of action, such as gaining power or the reforms which will be introduced afterwards.
Ideology provides the basis for the creation of political doctrines. Doctrines are more specific in comparison to ideology in terms of the methods that should be applied to achieve the goals and values set out in the ideology. Political programmes are created on the basis of doctrines. These programmes intend to implement specific aims in a particular place and time (socio‑political reality). Referring to ideology helps to convince the public of the necessity of the proposed changes.
Most of the main assumptions of modern political thought were born during the Enlightenmentthe Enlightenment. It was a time of social development, political emancipationemancipation of Western bourgeoisiebourgeoisie. During the Enlightenment in France, where the main philosophical foundations of this epoch were created, in the second half of the 18th century, a severe crisis of the state and the Church took place.
These two institutions, cooperating in the previous period, were the main authorities for the majority of French society. In the second half of the 18th century, due todue to internal events in France and the international situation, the ineptitudeineptitude of their actions became apparentapparent, and their moral declinemoral decline was revealed. It is difficult to preserve the authority in such a situation. At the same time it was a period of rapid development of an individual, the so‑called free professions began to develop, there were more and more educated people, new philosophical trends emergedemerged, questioning the Church as an intermediaryintermediary between man and God or denyingdenying the existence of God altogether.
Liberalism
In this completely new situation, which encouraged bold views to be expressed, the liberal doctrine was born. John Locke is regardedregarded as the main author of liberalism. Although not a Frenchman, he could observe social changes in the neighboring country. He could also see the effects of the development of manufactories and the first factories in his own country. His views became the basis for political liberalism, which was a doctrine developed by Charles Montesquieu and John Stuart Mill. Liberalism is a quite dynamic ideology. It has different varieties – from social Darwinism to social liberalism.
The main assumptions of liberalism are based on the concept of individual freedom, on an individual’s right to choose his own way of life. In the eighteenth century, supporters of liberalism assumed that people are born equal, that is why it is enough to introduce equality of the law and everyone can decide for themselves. They did not take into accounttake into account any cultural differences that result from the social position of each individual. They believed that everyone could be free and the only thing that should limit the individual’s freedom is the freedom of others. Contemporary advocates of liberalism notice the problem of cultural capital and express the view that the state has certain minimal obligations towards its citizens in the matter of enabling them to acquire education.
Another important assumption of liberalism is the existence of a free market economy. Adam Smith and David Ricardo are considered creators of economic liberalism. They wanted to limit the interference of the stateinterference of the state into the role of a „night watchmannight watchman”. This meant that it is the state's duty to ensure security for citizens, while the remaining spheres of life depend only on their own invention. Smith and Ricardo were supporters of the so‑called laissez‑faire. This view assumed total economic freedom and aversion to any elements of state intervention in the economy. Liberals were also advocatesadvocates of the separation of the state from the Church and leaving matters related to religious practices solely to the individual's decisions. This resulted in the necessity to introduce civil family legislation. Liberalism in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries underwentunderwent various transformations. A more modern representative of this doctrine was August Friedrich von Hayek. His book, “The Constitution of Liberty” is the basic guide for the views of modern liberals.
Conservatism
The answer to the liberal doctrine, which was based on the rejection of authorities, and especially the authority of the state and the Church, was the conservative doctrine, which was established at the beginning of the 19th century. Edmund Burke is considered one of the main creators of this doctrine. His most famous work, “Reflections on the Revolution in France”, is a direct assessment of the events in France at the end of the 18th century. It also contains the main assumptions of the new doctrine. The name conservatism (Latin conservatus – preserved), however, was used a little later. In 1820, François‑René de Chateaubriand published the first issue of his periodical under the title „Conservative”.
![Portret Edmunda Burke'a. Ubrany jest we frak i koszulę z koronkowym kołnierzem. Ma zaróżowione policzki i lekko rudawe włosy. Zwrócony jest lewym profilem do osoby patrzącej na obraz.](https://static.zpe.gov.pl/portal/f/res-minimized/R1QRxdC6ZJFBb/2/16xm5akRIeYzjAfg10SHhbOjIWaaV75h.jpg)
The main assumption of conservatism is basing all social and political activities on recognized authorities and a deep respect for the past and tradition. In contrast to liberals, conservatives are supporters of a strong state strengthened by the authority of the Church as an institution that cares about the morality of the individual. Supporters of this doctrine considered the class division of society to be natural and grant the right to exercise power only to the intellectual and cultural elites. At the time the doctrine was born, the conservatives believed that the only group that should have the right to exercise power is the aristocracy, because only in these families the traditions of power and education allow the selection of the best representatives. At the same time, they were advocates of the idea of “noblesse oblige”, which means “nobility obliges”. They understood this as an obligation to work for the common good and enlightenment of the lower social stratasocial strata. Contemporary conservatives, of course, appreciate the benefits of democracy.
In the field of economy, conservatives are advocates of the free market economy and state protection of property rightsproperty rights. They also believe that the social obligations of the state and the role of trade unions in the economy should be limited.
Tradition for conservatives is primarilyprimarily the life principles that you learn at home from your family. Conservatives, therefore, support multi‑generational families in which the individual gains cultural capital and learns to work for the social good. This is related to another conservative assumption, namely the view that each individual, in his place of the social laddersocial ladder, should work for the social good. In his life, conservatives claim, a citizen is supported by his religious community. Conservatives also have unanimousunanimous views on the issues of criminal law – they are advocates of severe punishment for committed crimes. Some of them also voice the necessity of reinstating the death penalty.
Socialism and communism
Implementation of the assumptions of the liberal economy allowed for the rapid economic development of European countries in the 19th century. Industrialisation led to a dramatic increase in the number of workers – a strong new social group was created. At the same time, the assumptions of a free market economy did not include labor rights. The mid‑nineteenth century, the period of the Spring of Nations, is the time of the birth of new social movements against all kinds of oppression, first of all national and social. In the year of the outbreak of European revolutions, a work was published by two German philosophers and economists, which became the basis of the new political doctrine, or rather two doctrines – social democracy and communism.
In “The Communist Manifesto” published in 1848, its authors, Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, refer to three basic areas: the views of utopian socialists previously operating in Europe and the United States, the political economy of capitalism and materialistic philosophy. The new doctrine, therefore, had a theoretical scientific basis.
The main assumptions of socialism, because this is what the first leftist views were ultimately called, was the cessationcessation of class struggleclass struggle, the introduction of common property, and the abolition of the state. The creators of the doctrine believed that the workers are able to decide for themselves, and the state is only a form of keepingkeeping the exploitedexploited groups (workers or proletariat, who do not own any means of productionmeans of production and have to sell their own labour power) in check and acts in the interests of the capitalists (owning the means of production and purchasing the labour power of others). Therefore, the slogan of the creators of the doctrine was “Workers of the world, unite!”. The slogan was supposed to provoke a Europe‑wide revolution caused by the awareness of their rights and expectations German workers as the best organized and conscious. After the end of the revolution, the borders between states were to disappear.
![Podpis: Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels are considered to be the fathers of communism, and Vladimir Lenin tried to implement their ideology. Czerwona flaga, na której umieszczono profile Marksa, Engelsa i Lenina.](https://static.zpe.gov.pl/portal/f/res-minimized/R1JlxwqlrRBzs/2/1rAMsjXa9sdQUSUEDkTcTAgy3ku853A0.jpg)
These views were not reflectedreflected in the activities of workers, and the industrial development brought diversity in their standard of living and expectations towards employers. At the same time, the introduction of universal suffrage in France and lowering the census of property in the parliamentary elections in the United Kingdom gave chances for political change without triggeringtriggering a revolution, but using the democratic principle. A crucialcrucial moment in the birth of two separate doctrines, derived from socialism, was the Second InternationalSecond International, which began its deliberationsdeliberations in 1889.
During the Second International, its participants divided into two groups: advocates of reformism, which was transformed into social democratic doctrine and supporters of revolutionism, who in the end created a slightly changed in relation to the views of Marx and Engels, communist doctrine.
Social Democrats (e.g. Ilia Berlin, Eduard Bernstein, Jack Jaures) began to proclaim the necessity and possibility of reforming capitalism through the parliamentary routethrough the parliamentary route. They believed that universal suffrage should be introduced in parliamentary elections, an eight‑hour day's work, paid holiday leaves, retirement pensions, pensions and health benefits for people who suffered accidents at work. From the original assumptions of socialism, the doctrine still retainsretains that the interests of the individual should be subordinated to the interests of the community. Their slogan was: to each according to his needs. This could have been perceived negatively, because it meant that hard work and commitment to the community would not always be well rewardedrewarded. However, the supporters of the doctrine proclaimed the need to reduce social differences, expecting full commitment from every citizen. From an economic point of view, the supporters of social democracy support the free market economy based on three types of ownership: private, cooperative and state. They wanted to reduce the differences between citizens by means of a tax system, in which the percentage of tax paid increases with the income of the taxpayer (progressive tax). They also support state interventionism.
The communist doctrine was also transformed. New supporters of communism, Vladimir Lenin and Leon Trotsky, believed that the process of raising the awareness of the proletariat could follow the communist revolution. In their views, the leading role of the Communist Party emerged, which should lead the revolutionary uprising, and after its victory, the education process was to take place. Like the creators of the communist doctrine (Marx, Engels), they believed that the revolution should reach all European countries (the whole world). The Communists were advocates of absolute equality, which was also supposed to manifest in access to consumer goods. They voiced the view that each individual deserves the same amount. They did not consider individual needs or commitment. They wanted to introduce a centrally planned state economy, which would enableenable the redistribution of goods. They did not see the need to create nation states. When the communist nation states ultimately emerged, they turned out to be a distortiondistortion of the self‑government and became states with undemocratic regimes. At present, the communist views are voiced by an insignificantinsignificant group of citizens of democratic countries. However, they try to include the principles of the democratic system in their views. The communist parties ceased to be anti‑systemic.
Compare three ideologies: conservatism, liberalism and social democracy. What are the main differences?
Choose one of the political ideologies: liberalism, conservatism, social democracy and analyze the ideology using a SWOT method. Present the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats connected to introducing the ideology. Consider the historical context and the contemporary situation.
Political ideologies have been and are an important element of the life of democratic societies. They allow political parties to shape recognizable programs, in which sometimes slogans define a political programme. Ideologies determine the place of political parties in the electoral market. Due to including the name of an ideology into the name of the party, it is easier for a citizen to accept or reject its ideas. Thanks to ideology, we can establish the attitude of its supporters to individual freedom, the state‑church relationship, or the level of state intervention in the economy. Knowing the theoretical foundations of ideology, it is easier for the citizen to find representatives with similar view of the world to his own.
Create a crossword in which the main password is the name of one of the ideologies, and the rest of the passwords are also connected to the subject.
Listen to the abstract recording to review the material and new vocabulary. Then do the vocabulary exercise. Match the pairs: English and Polish words.
interwencja państwa, pojawiać się, prawa własności, warstwa społeczna, walka klas, środki produkcji, trzymać w szachu, na drodze parlamentarnej
through the parliamentary route | |
to emerge | |
interference of the state | |
social stratum | |
property rights | |
class struggle | |
to keep in check | |
means of production |
Keywords
the left, the right, ideology, doctrine, political programme, liberalism, conservatism, communism, social democracy
Glossary
wskazywać
uzasadniać
Oświecenie
wyzwolenie
burżuazja, mieszczaństwo
dzięki (czemuś), z powodu
niestosowność, niezdolność
widoczny
upadek moralny
pojawiać się
pośrednik
zaprzeczać
być uważanym
brać pod uwagę
umożliwiać, pomagać, wspierać
interwencja państwa
stróż nocny
przechodzić (np. zmiany)
zwolennik
warstwa społeczna
prawa własności
w pierwszym rzędzie
drabina społeczna
jednakowy
zakończenie
walka klas
wyzyskiwany
środki produkcji
trzymać w szachu
odzwierciedlony
wywołać, być czynnikiem zapalnym
kluczowy
II Międzynarodówka
obrady
na drodze parlamentarnej
utrzymywać, zachowywać
wynagrodzony
zniekształcenie, wypaczenie
nieznaczący