The system of government of the Republic of Poland is based on the separation of and balance between the legislative, executive and judicial powers.
The judicial power in Poland is vested in courts and tribunals.
You will learn
You will be able to describe the court system in Poland and explain the jurisdictionjurisdictionjurisdiction of each of the courts: common, military and administrative.
You will be able to name and explain the competences of the Supreme Court, the Constitutional Tribunal, and the Tribunal of State.
R1xu4JWtArvnE
The court system
The Constitution of the Republic of Poland
Personal freedoms and rights
Article 45
Everyone shall have the right to a fair and public hearinghearinghearing of his case, without undue delayundue delayundue delay, before a competent, impartialimpartialimpartial and independent court.
Exceptions to the public nature of hearings may be made for reasons of morality, State security, public order or protection of the private life of a party, or other important private interest. Judgments shall be announced publicly.
konst Source: The Constitution of the Republic of Poland.
The structure of the judiciary in Poland
RvObs7AgqKcWN
Common courtssettleto settlesettle, among others, criminal, civil, family and guardianshipfamily and guardianship lawfamily and guardianship, and labour law cases, as well as all other matters that are not reserved for the jurisdiction of other courts.
Military courts deal first and foremostfirst and foremostfirst and foremost with matters related to offencesoffenceoffences committed by soldiers in active service.
Administrative courts primarily control the activities of public administration bodies, both governmental and self‑governmental (local governments). The control applies to, among others, administrative decisions, resolutions issued in administrative proceedingsresolution in administrative proceedingresolutions issued in administrative proceedings or complaints about inactivity of administrative bodies.
The Supreme Court supervises the judgements of common and military courts. There are two basic forms of such supervision: recognizing legal remedies against court rulingslegal remedies (against court rulings)legal remedies against court rulings adopting resolutions that resolve legal problems that raise doubt and discrepanciesdiscrepancydiscrepancies in the jurisprudencejurisprudencejurisprudence The competence of the Supreme Court also includes confirming the validityvalidityvalidity of the elections in accordance with principles specified by statute, as well as giving opinions on draft billsdraft billdraft bills and other legal acts.
RHw6rylBwQYqp
Exercise 1
Find three examples (e.g. online) of various cases settled by different organs of the judicial power. Analyze them and describe below.
RAyWa4qHc6Vlk
The Constitutional Tribunal
The Constitution of the Republic of Poland
The Constitutional Tribunal
Article 188
The Constitutional Tribunal shall adjudicateto adjudicateadjudicate regarding the following matters:
the conformityconformityconformity of statutes and international agreements to the Constitution;
the conformity of a statute to ratified international agreements whose ratification required prior consent granted by statute;
the conformity of legal provisions issued by central State organs to the Constitution, ratified international agreements and statutes;
konst1 Source: The Constitution of the Republic of Poland.
The main competence of the Constitutional Tribunal is to adjudicate regarding the conformity of statutes and other legal acts with the Constitution. The idea of controlling the constitutionality of law is based on the assumption that it is a hierarchical system, i.e. that the legal acts that are inferiorinferiorinferior cannot contain provisions that are contrary tocontrary tocontrary to the Constitution of other superiorsuperiorsuperior legal acts. Judgements of the Constitutional Tribunal are final. An act incompatible with the Constitution ceasesto ceaseceases to apply either at the moment of pronouncing the ruling or on a date determined by the Tribunal.
According to the Constitution, everyone whose constitutional freedoms or rights have been violated may bring a complaint concerning these infringementscomplaint concerning infringements of the Constitutioncomplaint concerning these infringements.
The Constitution of the Republic of Poland
Means for the defence of freedoms and rights
Article 79
In accordance with principles specified by statute, everyone whose constitutional freedoms or rights have been infringed, shall have the right to appeal to the Constitutional Tribunal for its judgment on the conformity to the Constitution of a statute or another normative act upon which basis a court or organ of public administration has made a final decision on his freedoms or rights or on his obligations specified in the Constitution.
konst2 Source: The Constitution of the Republic of Poland.
Other competencies of the Constitutional Tribunal include:
adjudicating regarding the conformity to the Constitution of the purposes or activities of political parties;
settling disputes over authority between central constitutional organs of the state.
The Tribunal of State
In modern democracies, constitutional accountability is, along with the political one, the most important form of executive power responsibility. It is the accountability for the violation of law. The procedure is initiated by the parliament, but the responsibility is incurred before the authority of the judiciary. In Poland it is the Tribunal of State.
The following persons are constitutionally accountable to the Tribunal of State:
R1GFZ1WRtoFSj
The types of punishment imposed by the Tribunal of State:
for crimes – punishments provided for in statutes;
for infringementinfringementinfringement of the Constitution – loss of electoral rights (for a period from 2 to 10 years), prohibition to hold managerial positions or perform public functions (for a period from 2 to 10 years), loss of all or some of the orders and decorationsorders and decorationsorders and decorations.
R8jRF4plilEp0
Exercise 2
RKZWrUgxEN10f
Exercise 3
Ćwiczenie alternatywne: Listen to the abstract recording to review the material and new vocabulary. Explain the meaning of following words: hearing; offence; validity; conformity; inferior; superior; to cease; infringement. If it's too difficult, use lesson's glossary.
Ćwiczenie alternatywne: Listen to the abstract recording to review the material and new vocabulary. Explain the meaning of following words: hearing; offence; validity; conformity; inferior; superior; to cease; infringement. If it's too difficult, use lesson's glossary.
Listen to the abstract recording to review the material and new vocabulary. Then do the vocabulary exercise. Match the pairs: English and Polish words.
judicial, jurisdiction, common/military/administrative courts, the Supreme Court, the Constitutional Tribunal, the Tribunal of State, constitutional accountability
Glossary
jurisdiction
jurisdiction
RueO4sPRAwa9V
jurysdykcja, zakres rozstrzyganych spraw
hearing
hearing
R12QydhP2rdhj
proces
undue delay
undue delay
RqnMkPZ6XPOE3
zbędna zwłoka, nieuzasadnione opóźnienie
impartial
impartial
R1EY5iUGDh0fV
bezstronny
to settle
to settle
RdmyyIi1KqR1d
rozstrzygać
family and guardianship law
family and guardianship law
R1aTpTvmdN7vG
prawo rodzinne i opiekuńcze
first and foremost
first and foremost
R1VcEohSkZwLL
przede wszystkim
offence
offence
R1TqXyw92XC8y
naruszenie prawa
resolution in administrative proceeding
resolution in administrative proceeding
R1cwz7ZzzmMrm
postanowienie w postępowaniu administracyjnym
legal remedies (against court rulings)
legal remedies (against court rulings)
RNx0jpUVu5bhr
środki odwoławcze (wobec orzeczeń sądu)
discrepancy
discrepancy
R1bSthhnRWaTg
rozbieżność
jurisprudence
jurisprudence
R17wzz4u0dJb2
prawoznawstwo
validity
validity
R1dbUJV4pmSHT
ważność
draft bill
draft bill
R1G2GFHR4xfGk
projekt ustawy
to adjudicate
to adjudicate
R5C3Jjz8yj1lY
orzekać
conformity
conformity
R1dPeOrBgwEzL
zgodność
inferior
inferior
Rw9a2V93gbZAf
niższego rzędu
superior
superior
RMycmZFjFNKxS
wyższego rzędu
contrary to
contrary to
RKgig0W9gx0AW
sprzeczne z
to cease
to cease
R1HP0hLUl9s8k
zaprzestać
complaint concerning infringements of the Constitution
complaint concerning infringements of the Constitution
RAjz68h4bUF4s
skarga konstytucyjna
infringement
infringement
RqOOsjS8NgWii
naruszenie
orders and decorations
orders and decorations
Rh0WoYHzEVlzK
ordery i odznaczenia
State Treasury
State Treasury
RH3UxTMPAFzlv
Skarb Państwa
National Bank of Poland
National Bank of Poland
REoWqiCtXYdUH
Narodowy Bank Polski
Supreme Chamber of Control
Supreme Chamber of Control
RnxtCj4BiSy1o
Najwyższa Izba Kontroli
National Council of Radio Broadcasting and Television
National Council of Radio Broadcasting and Television